0
0
Shimla, May 9, 2025:
In a significant ruling, the Himachal Pradesh High Court has declared that doctors who are willing to pay the full bond penalty amount cannot be compelled to serve the mandatory bond period at government institutions. The decision comes as a relief to medical professionals seeking career advancement opportunities outside their sponsoring institutions.
Background of the Case
The case centered on a pediatrician who completed his MBBS at Rajendra Prasad Government Medical College, Tanda, and later pursued further specialization at Indira Gandhi Medical College (IGMC), Shimla. After completing his Doctorate of Medicine (DM) in Neonatology, the doctor was appointed as an Assistant Professor at IGMC. In 2023, he was selected for a faculty position at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Bilaspur, and requested a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from IGMC to join the new post.
Despite his willingness to forfeit his bond by paying the stipulated penalty of Rs 60 lakh, the college authorities withheld the NOC, citing the state’s acute shortage of specialist doctors and the terms of his bond agreement, which required seven years of service after his super-specialty course.
Court’s Observations and Ruling
The High Court bench, led by Justice Sandeep Sharma, observed that the very purpose of the bond is to ensure doctors who benefit from government-sponsored education serve the state. However, the bond agreement also provides for the payment of a penalty in lieu of service. The court stated:
“Once the bond condition itself provides that in the event of violation of bond, bond amount shall be payable by the executant of bond, it cannot be said that even after deposit of bond money, in terms of bond executed by the petitioner, he can be compelled to work for the bond period.”
The court further noted that the public interest would not be compromised, as the doctor would continue to serve within Himachal Pradesh at a premier institution (AIIMS, Bilaspur), which offers advanced facilities in neonatology.
Directions Issued
The court directed the authorities at IGMC to issue the final NOC to the petitioner upon the deposit of the full bond amount. The resignation process was to be completed within three days of payment, ensuring a smooth transition for the doctor to his new role.
Implications
This judgment sets a precedent for medical professionals bound by similar service bonds. It clarifies that the payment of the bond penalty fulfills the contractual obligation, and the state cannot enforce both service and penalty simultaneously.
Disclaimer:
This article is based on information reported by Medical Dialogues and the official order of the Himachal Pradesh High Court. For full details and legal interpretations, readers are advised to consult the original court order and seek professional legal advice if required. The content here is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal counsel.
Citations:
